Yeah front light adjustments are made from plastic and they tend to break

I would suggest checking out Ebay for much better price on using lights BUT make sure they are OK. If you see a stype with front damage most likely adjustment plastic parts are broke so do not bid on these.
Remember that you need headlamps made for US so do not bid and order from let's say Germany.
From my own experience if your headlamps can't be adjusted up/down, then it can be usually fixed (glued or even a new small part made from aluminium if you have proper tools), if horizontal adjustment is not working - the part is a bit more complex and usually it can't be glued because there is a screw going thru it.
Make sure the color/wear matches your cars other headlamp. It was a bit strange for the looks when car's left side headlamp was much clearer than left side........ (this is why you can't order just one BRAND new headlamp...and you need get a used one if you are having problems with just one headlamp).